Come Hungry, Leave With Great Memories

MAKE A RESERVATION(opens in new tab)
Rustic restaurant interior with wooden decor.
Buffalo Bill's Restaurant & Tavern is a Show Low favorite. See our menu below the photo gallery.

Restaurant & Tavern Hours

Mon: Closed
Tue - Thu: 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Fri - Sun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Western-style building with buffalo sculptures outside.
Steak with baked potato and vegetables served.
Rustic restaurant interior with mounted animal heads.
Three colorful cocktails with buffalo illustrations.
Pepperoni pizza slice with dipping sauce.
Two beers on rustic wooden table.
Wild West-themed restaurant with cowboy mannequins.
Barbecue ribs with greens and drink.
Assorted wine bottles on a wooden table.
Rustic bar interior with wooden decor.
Burger with arugula and sweet potato fries.
Copper mug with ice and lime slices.
Fried fish fillets with lemon slices.

APPETIZERS

Burnt Ends
Melted Bleu Cheese / Spicy & Sweet BBQ Sauce / Green Onion Curls / Radish Garnish
16.00
Cheese Curd Poutine
Beer Battered White Cheddar Cheese Curds Served /Ranch
14.00
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Served with Bleu Cheese / Green Onions / Warm Tortilla Chips / Celery & Carrots
18.00
Cheese Curds
Beer Battered White Cheddar Cheese Curds Served with Marinara
13.00
Chicken Wings
Tossed in choice of: Buffalo / BBQ Mango Habanero / Sweet Chili Sauce / Ranch / Carrots / Celery
16.00
BLACKENED SHRIMP
Southwest Succotash / Bacon / Jalapenos / Corn Black Beans / Green Chilis / Comeback Sauce / Grilled Bread
15.00
CHICKEN ARTICHOKE FLATBREAD
Pesto / Rotisserie Chicken / Artichokes Goat Cheese / Balsamic Glaze
18.00
Plate of fries with drinks and burger.
Burger with waffle fries and drinks.

BURGERS & SANDWICHES

Featuring buns and bread from Baked in Pinetop. Pick one side.

AZ CHEESEBURGER 1/2 lb
18.00
BISON CHEESEBURGER
24.00
BBQ PULLED PORK SANDWICH
House Smoked Pork / BBQ Sauce / Coleslaw
17.00
BBQ BRISKET SANDWICH
House Smoked Brisket with BBQ Sauce
19.00
THE GUNSLINGER
Wagyu Beef / Bourbon Bacon Jam / Swiss Cheese / Arugula
25.00
COWBOY DIP
Shaved Roast Beef on Griddled Rye Pepper Jack / Creamy Horseradish / Roasted Green Chili / Sauteed Mushrooms
20.00
WHITE MOUNTAIN CHEESESTEAK
Shaved Prime Rib / Pepper Jack / Onions / Bell Peppers / Served with Comeback Sauce on a Hoagie Roll
19.00
SOUTHWEST CHICKEN SANDWICH
Marinated Chicken Breast / Pepper Jack / Roasted Green Chili / Comeback Sauce
18.00
** BURGER & SANDWICH ADDITIONS
bacon / sautéed onions / sautéed mushrooms / green chili / jalapeños / Gluten free bun $3
2.00 each

Entrees

Choose 2 sides

BBQ BABY BACK RIBS
Half or Full
30.00H | 38.00 F
1/3 LB BBQ BRISKET
26.00
1/3 LB BBQ PULLED PORK
25.00
SMOKED SAUSAGE (2)
Jalapeno Cheddar
19.00
ROTISSERIE CHICKEN – HALF
Pick One: Cajun, Lemon Herb, Mango Habanero Glaze, Sweet Chili Glaze
22.00
RIBEYE 14 oz
44.00
Barbecue ribs with greens and beans.
FILET 8 OZ
46.00
SALMON 7OZ
Mango Habanero Glaze with Mango Salsa
34.00
BBQ PLATTER
¼ LB BBQ Brisket ¼ LB Pulled Pork 1 Smoked Sausage ½ Rack Baby Back Ribs ¼ Rotisserie Chicken Pickles/Onions / Bourbon Beans / Mac & Cheese / Coleslaw NO SUBSTITUTIONS
60.00
COUNTRY FRIED STEAK
23.00
SPAGHETTI BOLOGNESE
House Made Bolognese, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Grilled Garlic Bread (Does not include side)
20.00
** Additions
Sautéed Onions +5 , Sautéed Mushrooms +5, Grilled Shrimp +9
CORN COBETTE
4.00
ASPARAGUS
8.00
CREAMY COLESLAW
4.00
BOURBON BAKED BEANS
6.00
FRENCH FRIES
Add Loaded +4
5.00
ONION RINGS
6.00
MASHED POTATOES
Add Country Gravy +2
5.00
BAKED POTATO
Add Loaded +4, Add BBQ Brisket or BBQ Pulled Pork +8
8.00
MAC & CHEESE
Add Burnt Ends +6
8.00
SOUTHWEST MAC & CHEESE
Bacon/Green Chili / Jalapeños Choose Blackened Chicken Breast or Blackened Shrimp (Docs not include sides)
21.00
BLACKENED ROCKFISH & SHRIMP
Southwest Wild Rice / Creole Sauce / Crispy Onions
27.00
Grilled bread with drink by cozy fireplace.
Pizza with sausage and green peppers topping.

PIZZA & FLATBREAD

Home-made Crust. Gluten Free Crust +2. Topping Options: Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Chicken, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Bell Peppers, Green Chilis, Jalapenos, Onions, Mushrooms, Extra Cheese

BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA
PICK 3 TOPPINGS - Pepperoni/Sausage / Bacon / Chicken / Tomatoes / Black Olives / Bell Peppers / Green Chilis / Jalapenos / Onions / Mushrooms / Extra Cheese
20.00
CHEESE PIZZA
17.00
PEPPERONI PIZZA
18.00
HICKOCK PIZZA
Sausage / Bacon / Green Chili
20.00
BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
House Rotisserie Chicken Red Onions / Cilantro / BBQ Sauce / Mozzarella Cheese
20.00
SUPREME PIZZA
Pepperoni / Sausage / Mushrooms / Bell Peppers / Black Olives / Onions
21.00
MARGHERITA PIZZA
Tomatoes/Fresh Mozzarella/Basil
18.00

soup & salads

Salad Additions: Add Rotisserie* or Crispy Chicken +5, Steak +7, Salmon +9

CAESAR SALAD
10.00 SM | 13.00 LG
HOUSE SALAD
Mixed Greens & Romaine / Tomatoes / Cucumbers / Cheese Blend / Croutons / Tossed in House Made Ranch Dressing
10.00 SM | 13.00 LG
CHOPPED SALAD
Mixed Greens & Romaine / Hard Boiled Egg / Bacon / Goat Cheese / Tossed in House Made Ranch Dressing
15.00
TAVERN SALAD
Mixed Greens & Romaine Spiced Pecans / Dried Cranberries / Bleu Cheese Crumbles / Tossed in Prickly Pear Vinaigrette
17.00
SOUTHWEST CORN CHOWDER
Roasted Corn, Black Beans, Bacon
7.00 C | 9.00 B
SOUP OF THE DAY
7.00 C | 9.00 B
CAPRESE SALAD
Mixed Greens & Romaine /Spiced Pecans/Dried Cranberries / Bleu Cheese Crumbles / Tossed in Prickly Pear Vinaigrette
17.00

SIDES

CORN COBETTE
4.00
ASPARAGUS
8.00
CREAMY COLESLAW
4.00
BOURBON BAKED BEANS
6.00
FRENCH FRIES
Add Loaded +4
5.00
ONION RINGS
6.00
MASHED POTATOES
Add Country Gravy +2
5.00
BAKED POTATO
Add Loaded +4, Add BBQ Brisket or BBQ Pulled Pork +8
8.00
MAC & CHEESE
Add Burnt Ends +6
8.00

Dessert

S’Mores Peanut Butter Flatbread
12.00
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake
12.00
4 Layer Carrot Cake
12.00
5 Layer Chocolate Cake
12.00